
The Concord of the Five Religions
Chapter 5 Confucianism
Part 7: A Comparative Study of East Asian Religions: Confucianism, Buddhism, Daoism, and Shinto
The religious systems of East Asia—represented primarily by Confucianism, Buddhism, Daoism, and Shinto—originated in China and Japan but have historically interacted and merged with one another. Confucianism emphasizes ethics and social order; Buddhism seeks liberation and compassion; Daoism focuses on nature and longevity; and Shinto centers on the worship of deities and ancestors. As of 2025, these religions display diverse characteristics under the influence of globalization and modernity.
1. Origins and Historical Background
Confucianism
Confucianism originated during China’s Spring and Autumn Period (770–476 BCE) and was founded by Confucius (551–479 BCE). He reorganized the rituals of the Zhou dynasty and the “Six Classics,” proposing the ideals of ren (benevolence) and li (ritual), aiming to restore social harmony.
During the reign of Emperor Wu of the Han Dynasty (141–87 BCE), Dong Zhongshu promoted the doctrine of “honoring Confucianism exclusively,” making it the ideological foundation of the state.
Buddhism
Buddhism began in 5th-century BCE India and was founded by Siddhartha Gautama (Gautama Buddha, 563–483 BCE), who taught the Four Noble Truths and the Eightfold Path.
It entered China in the 1st century CE through the Silk Road. Emperor Ming of the Eastern Han (reigned 58–75 CE) established the White Horse Temple, marking the beginning of Buddhism’s integration into East Asia.
Daoism
Daoism emerged in the 2nd century CE during the Eastern Han Dynasty. Zhang Daoling founded the Celestial Masters movement, drawing on the philosophical foundations of Laozi’s Dao De Jing.
Daoism absorbed folk beliefs and esoteric practices, emphasizing “following the natural Way” and the pursuit of immortality. By the Wei and Jin periods, a complete religious system had formed.
Shinto
Shinto originated in ancient Japan; its nature and ancestor worship can be traced back to the Yayoi period (3rd century BCE).
After the introduction of Buddhism in the 6th century, Shinto was influenced by it and developed the shrine system alongside the idea of “Shinbutsu-shūgō” (the amalgamation of kami and Buddhas).
During the Meiji Restoration (from 1868), Shinto was established as a state religion and separated from Buddhism.
Comparisons and Interactions
Origins: Confucianism and Daoism began in China; Buddhism came from India; Shinto developed independently in Japan.
Context: Confucianism responded to social disorder; Buddhism reformed Brahmanism; Daoism absorbed folk spirituality; Shinto reflected indigenous nature worship.
Interaction: Buddhism influenced both Confucianism and Daoism after entering East Asia; Shinto coexisted with Buddhism for over a millennium.
2. Doctrines and Core Concepts
Confucianism
Benevolence and Ritual: Emphasizes love and order—“Do not impose on others what you do not desire yourself” (Analects, Yan Yuan).
Mandate of Heaven: Dong Zhongshu proposed mutual responsiveness between Heaven and humanity.
Self-Cultivation: From filial piety to “governing the state and pacifying all under Heaven” (from The Great Learning), focusing on this-worldly concerns.
Buddhism
Four Noble Truths: Suffering, its cause, its cessation, and the path toward liberation.
Karma and Rebirth: Actions determine destiny; no eternal self exists.
Compassion: The ideal of saving all beings, especially in Mahāyāna Buddhism with its Bodhisattva path.
Daoism
Following the Natural Way: As Laozi said, “Man follows Earth, Earth follows Heaven, Heaven follows the Dao, and the Dao follows what is natural” (Dao De Jing).
Immortality: Pursuit of longevity through alchemy and inner cultivation.
Yin-Yang and Five Phases: The cosmos operates through dynamic balance.
Shinto
Kami Worship: Everything has spirit (the “eight million kami”); the emperor is seen as a descendant of Amaterasu.
Purity and Pollution: Ritual purification (harae) removes defilement.
Ancestor Veneration: Kami and ancestors are interconnected, emphasizing lineage.
Comparative Insights
Cosmology: Confucian Heaven is moral order; the Buddhist universe is cyclical; the Daoist Way is natural law; Shinto kami are personal deities.
Goals: Confucianism seeks social order; Buddhism seeks liberation; Daoism seeks longevity; Shinto seeks safety and harmony.
Common Themes: Confucian ren, Buddhist compassion, Daoist harmony, and Shinto reverence all incline toward social harmony.
3. Practices and Rituals
Confucianism
Rituals: Heaven worship, ancestor worship, Confucius ceremonies—mostly cultural activities in 2025.
Education: From imperial exams to modern “national studies.”
Daily Practice: Filial piety, etiquette, and family-centered traditions such as Lunar New Year gatherings.
Buddhism
Practice: Chanting, meditation, ethical discipline (e.g., Five Precepts).
Rituals: Burning incense, reciting scriptures, rituals such as the Ghost Festival.
Charity: Supporting monks and doing good deeds.
Daoism
Cultivation: Internal alchemy, meditation, talismans, pursuit of immortality.
Rituals: Ceremonies, blessings, exorcisms; Daoist priests also conduct funerals.
Health Practices: Qigong and Taiji, widely practiced today.
Shinto
Rituals: Shrine visits, purification rites, festivals (e.g., New Year prayers).
Daily Practice: Household altars and prayers for safety.
Celebrations: The Shichi-Go-San festival marking children’s growth.
Comparative Insights
Forms: Confucianism has become secular; Buddhism and Daoism remain focused on spiritual cultivation; Shinto emphasizes ritual.
Places: Confucianism lacks fixed religious institutions; Buddhism has temples; Daoism has monasteries; Shinto has shrines.
In 2025: Confucian rituals are culturalized; Buddhism and Daoism maintain religious practice; Shinto is deeply woven into Japanese life.
4. Social Influence and Functions
Confucianism
Politics: Served as state ideology since the Han Dynasty; imperial examinations shaped the scholar-official class.
Ethics: The Three Bonds and Five Relationships guided social norms.
2025 Influence: Affects education and governance, such as concepts of social harmony.
Buddhism
Spiritual: Provides paths to liberation; Pure Land Buddhism is deeply rooted among common people.
Culture: Influences art, scriptures, and architecture (e.g., cave temples).
2025 Influence: Active in charity and meditation programs.
Daoism
Folk Influence: Shapes geomancy, traditional medicine, and festivals.
Social Role: Offers mystical comfort and protection.
2025 Influence: Health-related Daoist practices have merged with wellness industries.
Shinto
Politics: Was the state religion during the Meiji era, reinforcing national identity.
Culture: Influences Japanese festivals and architecture.
2025 Influence: Integrated into daily life; some shrines serve as tourist sites.
Comparative Insights
Power Relations: Confucianism and Shinto were state-supported; Buddhism and Daoism remained relatively independent.
Impact Areas: Confucianism—order; Buddhism—spirituality; Daoism—folk life; Shinto—national identity.
Contemporary Trends: Confucianism and Daoism have become cultural; Buddhism is globalizing; Shinto remains localized.
5. Globalization and Contemporary Forms
Confucianism
Spread: Through East Asian cultural spheres and Confucius Institutes (over 500 by 2025).
Current State: More cultural than religious.
Challenge: Lack of universal or missionary framework.
Buddhism
Spread: Across Asia and worldwide; approximately 500 million followers in 2025.
Current State: Zen and Tibetan Buddhism are popular in the West, influencing mindfulness movements.
Strength: Spiritual practices appeal across cultures.
Daoism
Spread: Mainly within Chinese communities; partially adopted in the West.
Current State: Taiji and Qigong are popular globally; religious Daoism remains limited.
Challenge: Fragmented institutions hinder global transmission.
Shinto
Spread: Mostly confined to Japan; small communities exist abroad.
Current State: Integrated into Japanese society; limited global impact.
Characteristic: Strong national identity restricts international expansion.
Comparative Insights
Global Scope: Buddhism is the most global; Confucianism follows; Daoism and Shinto remain regional.
Adaptability: Buddhism is flexible; Confucianism spreads through culture; Daoism and Shinto face regional constraints.
2025 Trends: Buddhism shows the most religious vitality; Confucianism and Daoism are culturalized; Shinto is nationalized.
6. Interactions and Syncretism
Confucianism-Buddhism-Daoism: Integrated into the “Three Teachings” model during the Tang Dynasty; Neo-Confucianism incorporated Buddhist introspection; Daoist longevity practices influenced Confucian self-cultivation.
Shinto-Buddhism: Japan developed “Shinbutsu-shūgō,” worshipping Buddhas and kami together.
2025 Scene: Confucianism influences governance; Buddhism and Daoism complement folk beliefs; Shinto maintains a distinctive identity.
7. Conclusion: Values and Insights of East Asian Religions
Confucianism, Buddhism, Daoism, and Shinto represent the rich diversity of East Asian civilization. Confucianism builds social order; Buddhism nourishes spirituality; Daoism promotes harmony with nature; and Shinto connects humans with deities and ancestors.
By 2025, Confucianism and Daoism have become cultural, Buddhism has global influence, and Shinto remains tied to Japanese identity. Together, they continue to shape East Asian society and offer wisdom and reflection for the modern world.
