Chapter 5 Confucianism

Part 3: The Historical Development of Confucianism


The historical evolution of Confucianism is a process in which ritual culture transformed into a state ideology and ultimately into a modern cultural symbol. Unlike typical religions, the development of Confucianism was deeply shaped by political conditions, blending religious, philosophical, and ethical elements. From its intellectual origins in the pre-Qin era to its institutionalization in the Han dynasty, the peak of its religious dimensions during the Tang and Song dynasties, and its secularization and revival in the modern era, Confucianism underwent multiple transformations. This section traces its development by historical periods and examines its role and significance in Chinese history.

1. Pre-Qin Period: Origins and Foundations (ca. 2000 BCE – 221 BCE)

Roots in Ancient Ritual Culture

The origins of Confucianism can be traced back to the religious and social practices of the Xia, Shang, and Zhou dynasties. Although the Xia dynasty (ca. 2070–1600 BCE) left few textual records, archaeological evidence shows sacrificial sites that reveal established traditions of worshipping Heaven and Earth. The Shang dynasty (ca. 1600–1046 BCE), through oracle bone inscriptions, provides clear evidence of the veneration of Di (the supreme deity). Shang rulers relied on divination and human sacrifice to communicate with the divine, laying the groundwork for a tradition in which religion and political authority were intertwined.

The Zhou dynasty (1046–256 BCE) was the crucial period for the formation of Confucianism. The Duke of Zhou institutionalized a ritual and music system based on earlier Shang practices, establishing a clan-based social structure. He formalized the concept of the Mandate of Heaven, asserting that the ruler governed with heavenly approval contingent on his virtue. Rituals such as sacrifices to Heaven and ancestors, as recorded in the Zhou Rituals, became foundational to the later religious aspects of Confucianism. As the Western Zhou declined and warfare escalated during the Eastern Zhou era, disorder in the ritual system provided fertile ground for the birth of Confucian thought.

Confucius and the Founding of Confucianism

In the Spring and Autumn Period (770–476 BCE), Confucius (551–479 BCE), reacting to the collapse of ritual order, promoted the idea of “returning to ritual.” He compiled and systematized the Six Classics (Poetry, Documents, Rituals, Music, Changes, and Spring and Autumn Annals), established private education, and trained more than three thousand disciples. His doctrines of ren (benevolence) and li (ritual) laid the philosophical groundwork for Confucianism.

Differentiation During the Warring States

The Warring States Period (475–221 BCE) saw the flourishing of competing schools of thought. Confucianism gained strength through internal diversification. Mencius (372–289 BCE) advanced the doctrine of the goodness of human nature and advocated benevolent government based on the welfare of the people. Xunzi (313–238 BCE), in contrast, argued that human nature is inherently bad and emphasized ritual and law as tools for order. Although Confucianism had not yet become dominant, its educational tradition and ethical framework were already established among the educated class.

2. Qin and Han Dynasties: Consolidation and Religious Development (221 BCE – 220 CE)
Suppression Under the Qin

When Qin Shi Huang unified China in 221 BCE, he adopted Legalist doctrines. At the suggestion of the minister Li Si, he ordered the burning of books and the burying alive of scholars (213–212 BCE), which targeted Confucian texts and scholars. Confucianism suffered a severe setback, but the Qin regime collapsed quickly (206 BCE), allowing its recovery.

Rise and Institutionalization in the Western Han

In the early Western Han (from 202 BCE), Daoist-Huang-Lao thought dominated. Confucianism remained marginal until Emperor Wu (141–87 BCE), who accepted the proposal of Dong Zhongshu to “ban all other schools and honor Confucianism exclusively.” He established the Imperial University (Taixue) with the Five Classics as the curriculum, turning Confucianism into the state ideology.

Dong Zhongshu developed the theory of the interaction between Heaven and humanity, arguing that cosmic order responded to political morality and that disasters signaled the ruler’s moral failings. He also systematized the “Three Bonds and Five Constants,” linking Confucian ethics directly to governance and cosmology.

During this time, the state sacrificial system took shape. The emperor conducted sacrifices to Heaven and Mount Tai, while Confucian scholars supervised state rituals and ancestral ceremonies. In 1 CE, the descendants of Confucius were granted hereditary titles, and Confucian temples became sites of official worship—marking the religious institutionalization of Confucianism.

Expansion and Crisis in the Eastern Han

The Eastern Han (25–220 CE) continued the official support for Confucianism.
In 79 CE, the White Tiger Hall Conference produced the Debates of the White Tiger Hall, which standardized canonical interpretations.
However, political corruption and widespread uprisings such as the Yellow Turban Rebellion weakened Confucian authority toward the end of the Han dynasty.

3. Wei, Jin, and Northern and Southern Dynasties: Competition and Syncretism (220–589)

Decline During the Three Kingdoms

During the Three Kingdoms period, constant warfare limited Confucianism’s moral and social functions. Although Cao Cao employed Confucian scholars, practical concerns outweighed ritual governance.

Influence of Neo-Daoist “Mysterious Learning”

In the Western Jin (265–316), Neo-Daoist thinkers such as Wang Bi and He Yan interpreted Confucian classics—especially the Book of Changes—through the lens of Laozi and Zhuangzi. This emphasized metaphysics, spontaneity, and naturalness, enriching the philosophical dimension of Confucianism.

Three Teachings Co-exist

During the Northern and Southern Dynasties (420–589), Buddhism flourished and Daoism formalized into an organized religion. In the north, regimes like the Northern Wei respected Confucianism and maintained the Imperial Academy but favored Buddhism even more. In the south, Confucianism blended with Buddhism, creating hybrid intellectual traditions. Confucianism remained the state ideology in principle but turned more toward ethical education rather than cosmology or ritual authority. Some rulers, such as Emperor Wu of Northern Zhou (561–578), promoted a synthesis of the Three Teachings.

4. Sui and Tang Dynasties: Splendor and Transformation (581–907)

Restoration Under the Sui

The Sui dynasty (581–618) restored Confucian education, reestablished the Imperial Academy, and created an early form of the civil service examinations.

Peak Under the Tang

The Tang dynasty (618–907) marked a peak for Confucianism. Emperor Taizong honored Confucius as the “First Sage,” established national and imperial academies, and formalized the examination system. Emperor Xuanzong later elevated Confucius to “King of Proclaiming Culture,” and Confucian temples spread nationwide. Ritual worship of Confucius reached its highest ritual status during this era.

During this time, Confucianism interacted with Buddhism and Daoism. After Emperor Wuzong’s persecution of Buddhism in 845, Confucian influence strengthened. Han Yu (768–824) criticized Buddhism and articulated the concept of the Confucian “lineage of the Way,” affirming Confucianism as the true moral tradition from sage rulers down to Confucius and Mencius.

5. Song and Yuan Dynasties: Philosophical Development and Expansion (960–1368)

Rise of Neo-Confucianism in the Song

The Song dynasty saw major philosophical developments. Zhou Dunyi’s Explanation of the Diagram of the Supreme Ultimate laid groundwork for Neo-Confucian cosmology. The Cheng brothers (Cheng Hao and Cheng Yi) proposed the concept of Heavenly Principle. Zhu Xi (1130–1200) systematized these ideas into a comprehensive Neo-Confucian system, emphasizing “preserving heavenly principle and eliminating human desires” and advocating the method of “investigating things to attain knowledge.” His interpretations of the Four Books became orthodox for centuries.

Through the examination system, Neo-Confucianism became deeply influential in Chinese society and government.

Decline and Revival in the Yuan

The Mongol-led Yuan dynasty initially suppressed Confucianism, favoring Buddhist and Tibetan religious institutions. The civil service examinations were suspended and later restored by Emperor Renzong (1311–1320). Confucianism recovered but did not regain full dominance.

6. Ming and Qing Dynasties: Consolidation and Secularization (1368–1911)

Ming: The Rise of Wang Yangming’s Philosophy

During the Ming dynasty, Confucianism flourished once more. Wang Yangming (1472–1529) proposed the philosophy of the mind, asserting that “the mind is principle” and advocating the practice of “extending innate knowledge.” His thought emphasized moral intuition and action, complementing and challenging Zhu Xi’s rationalism.

The imperial examination system reached its height, spreading Confucian learning throughout society.

Qing: Evidential Scholarship and Decline

The Qing dynasty reaffirmed Zhu Xi’s Neo-Confucian orthodoxy. Emperor Kangxi personally performed sacrifices at Confucian temples. However, the rise of evidential scholarship under thinkers like Gu Yanwu and Dai Zhen shifted focus toward philology and textual analysis. This diminished Confucianism’s religious dimension.

After the Opium War (1840), Western thought and Christianity posed new challenges, and Confucianism’s authority weakened further.

7. Modern Era: Crisis and Revival (1911–2025)

Decline After the 1911 Revolution

The fall of the Qing ended the imperial Confucian state. Kang Youwei’s attempt to establish “Confucianism” (Kongjiao) as the national religion failed. The May Fourth Movement (1919) criticized Confucianism as feudal and outdated, accelerating its decline.

20th Century: Marginalization and Reflection

After the founding of the People’s Republic of China in 1949, Confucianism was sidelined. During the Cultural Revolution (1966–1976), Confucian temples were destroyed and Confucian teachings were denounced. With economic reforms in the 1980s, traditional culture revived, bringing renewed interest in Confucian ideas.

21st Century: Cultural Revival and Global Reach (to 2025)

In the early 21st century, Confucianism re-emerged as a cultural—and to some extent political—symbol. Since 2004, Confucius Institutes have promoted Chinese culture globally. By 2025, Confucian ceremonies such as the annual Confucius Commemoration have returned, and Confucian ethics have been incorporated into educational and social governance frameworks.

Its religious dimensions, however, have largely faded; Confucianism is now regarded primarily as a cultural and philosophical heritage.

8. Conclusion: The Historical Significance of Confucianism

The history of Confucianism reflects its adaptability and multifaceted nature. From its ethical roots in the pre-Qin period, through its religious institutionalization in the Han, its philosophical maturation in the Tang and Song, and its modern secularization and revival, Confucianism has remained deeply connected to the social and political rhythms of China.

Although no longer a dominant religion in 2025, its values continue to shape East Asian culture and remain an enduring force in modern society.