Volume II: Diagnosis of Failure and the End of the Dream

Part VII: Cultural Civil War: America’s Battle for Its Soul

Chapter 105: The Sanctification of State Power: The Romanticization of Tyranny — Transforming the State Apparatus into an Ideological Weapon


This chapter will summarize the alienation of the right-wing ideology’s conception of state power. We will analyze how right-wing populists view the state apparatus as a “sacred tool” to achieve their sacred mission (white nationalism, Chapter 102) and defeat cultural enemies (the “Great Replacement Theory,” Chapter 101). This shift in perspective marks a fundamental departure from the founding principles of the United States—separation of powers and checks and balances—and rationalizes the suppression of dissenters and minority groups, paving the way for the institutionalization of political violence.

First Thesis: The Subversion of Traditional Conceptions of Power

I. The American Founding Principle’s View of Power

The founding principles of the United States, as articulated in The Federalist Papers, reflect a deep wariness of absolute power. The core of the system’s design is the separation of powers and checks and balances (Chapter 51), intended to prevent any single faction or individual from abusing state power. Power is viewed as dangerous, a tool that must be constrained.

II. The Right-Wing Populist New View of Power: The Simplification of the Tool

Right-wing populism subverts this wariness, simplifying and sanctifying the concept of power:

Goal-Oriented: Power is no longer a dangerous entity to be checked, but an efficient tool to achieve a single, sacred goal (saving America).

Endowment of Sanctity: Since “our” goals are morally and theologically righteous (Chapter 102), “our” use of state power cannot be considered tyranny, but rather a “necessary correction.”

Romanticization of Tyranny: The romanticization of the strongman leader emerges, with the belief that only a leader who breaks the rules and bypasses the system can fight against “corrupt elites and traitors” (Chapter 104).

Second Thesis: Weaponizing State Power: Suppressing the Enemy

III. Rejection of Institutional Neutrality

In the right-wing populist narrative, they do not believe government institutions (such as the FBI, the Department of Justice, the military) are neutral. Rather, they are told by media echo chambers (Chapter 104) that these institutions have been “captured” by “woke elites” and the “Deep State.”

Double Standard: When they are out of power, they view these institutions as tools of tyranny; when they are in power, they advocate “cleansing” these institutions to serve “our cause.”

The Essence of “Cleansing”: The essence of “cleansing” is to remove all political dissenters from institutions and replace them with individuals ideologically loyal, transforming the civil service system into a political tool.

IV. Rationalizing the Suppression and Exclusion of Dissenters

The ultimate goal of sanctifying state power is to rationalize the suppression and exclusion of “enemies” in the cultural civil war:

Moral Isolation: Since progressives, secularists, and immigrants are viewed as participants in the “Great Replacement conspiracy” and “enemies of God” (Chapters 101 and 102), they are no longer legitimate political opponents but threats to be suppressed and punished.

Instrumentalization of Law: Laws and law enforcement agencies are required to serve a single ideological purpose. For example, using the Department of Justice and law enforcement to investigate, prosecute, and intimidate political opponents, while showing tolerance for political violence from within the in-group (Chapter 92’s undermining of judicial independence).

Deprivation of Citizenship: Implicit or explicit restrictions on the civil rights of “disloyal” citizens, such as limiting the voting rights of minority groups and urban voters through stricter voting laws (Chapter 33).

Third Thesis: The Destruction of Institutions and the Romanticization of Violence

V. Systematic Attacks on the Separation of Powers

The sanctification and romanticization of state power inevitably lead to systematic attacks on the American constitutional system of separation of powers:

Expansion of Executive Power: Populist leaders argue that executive power should not be constrained by the legislature (Congress) or the judiciary (courts), because they represent the “true will of the people.”

“Delegitimization” of Law: Any laws or checks and balances that obstruct “taking back the country” are viewed as immoral and needing to be dismantled.

VI. The Romanticization of Tyranny and the Allure of “Strongman Politics”

This ideology creates a longing for “strongman politics” among the populace:

Efficiency First: Faced with the reality of political paralysis (Chapter 39) and institutional incompetence (Chapter 90), many are inclined to accept a powerful leader who can “get things done,” even at the cost of procedural justice and individual liberty.

Reimagining “Tyranny”: The traditional fear of “tyranny” is replaced by fear of “chaos and decline” (Chapter 99). A “tyrant” who can bring order and cultural purity is seen as a “savior,” not an oppressor. This represents the most profound betrayal of democratic values.

Fourth Thesis: Chapter Conclusion: The Complete Vicious Cycle of the Right-Wing Engine

Chapter 105 completes the analysis of the right-wing engine of the cultural civil war, forming a vicious cycle from anxiety to faith to conception of power:

Emergence of Anxiety: The sense of loss of white privilege and economic deprivation (Chapter 103).

Identification of the Enemy: The “Great Replacement Theory” transforms anxiety into racial fear targeting elites and outsiders (Chapter 101).

Bestowal of Morality: White nationalism sanctifies political struggle as a battle between good and evil (Chapter 102).

Acquisition of the Tool: The romanticization of state power provides permission for suppressing dissent and institutional exclusion.

Presentation of the Core Argument: Right-wing populism alienates state power from a tool to be checked into a weapon for achieving a sacred mission. This romanticization of tyranny directly attacks the core structure of American democracy and rationalizes the systematic suppression of opponents in the cultural civil war, pushing the culture war to the brink of institutional violence.